Tech

22 electric cars in comparison – German model in front

How far can an electric car really go? The Norwegian Automobile Club NAF tested 22 current models under real conditions. The results sometimes differ significantly from the manufacturer’s information. A BMW is surprisingly clear at the top, while a Chinese model remains almost twelve percent below its promise. An overview.

The range of electric cars on paper is one thing, the actual mileage is another. In order to get to the bottom of the discrepancy between the manufacturer’s information and reality, the Norwegian automobile club NAF carries out its large-scale El Prix range test twice a year. For the 2026 summer edition, 22 popular electric cars with fully charged batteries were sent onto the track to test how far they can go.

22 electric cars in comparison: This is how the range test went

To ensure that the conditions are fair and comparable for all vehicles, at the El Prix all electric cars tested drive the same route through Norway on the same day at the same speed. The temperatures on the day of the test were between a mild 12 and 18 degrees, and the roads were dry throughout. The route consisted of a balanced mix of city traffic, country roads and motorways.

However, it should be noted that speeds of more than 110 km/h are rarely permitted in Norway. This relatively low speed for German drivers suits electric cars because it reduces consumption. On the other hand, the route was mostly uphill, which at least partially offset this factor.

The distance traveled up to the point at which a vehicle reduces its performance was measured. Unlike a combustion engine, an electric car does not stop abruptly when the battery is almost empty, but instead switches to a kind of emergency mode in which, among other things, the top speed is limited. As soon as this moment occurred, the NAF testers evaluated the distance covered up to that point.

From a German perspective, the results of the study are encouraging. The victory goes to a premium model from Bavaria: the BMW iX3. The electric SUV left all 21 competitors behind and covered by far the longest distance of 781 kilometers. To put it into perspective: This roughly corresponds to the distance from Berlin to Brussels. The second-placed Lucid Gravity only covered 720 kilometers and therefore stopped a full 61 kilometers earlier than the iX3.

Manufacturers often provide optimistic information

In addition to the pure range, another value is particularly interesting: the deviation of the manufacturer’s information from the actual performance. However, the result is not entirely negative, as around half of the electric cars in the test actually drove further than promised. The clear winner in this discipline is the Chinese electric car Xpeng X9, which went 11.4 percent further than stated (646 instead of 580 kilometers). Such a value cannot be taken for granted in a heavy seven-seater.

The bottom performer in this category also comes from a Chinese brand. With a negative deviation of 11.7 percent, the MG IM6 fell well short of expectations and only traveled 446 kilometers instead of the promised 505. This is surprising, especially since the sister model MG S6 achieved an increase of 3.4 percent.

One rule with batteries is to never fully charge or empty them in order to increase their durability. Accordingly, you should never drive an electric car completely empty in everyday life, because in the worst case scenario this can damage the battery. That’s why the NAF also recorded how far each car would have gotten if the test had been stopped with a remaining charge of 20 or 10 percent.

An example that illustrates the relevance of these values ​​is the Toyota bZ4X. In the test, this was able to achieve exactly its specified WLTP range of 506 kilometers. However, with 10 percent remaining battery, he had only covered 429 kilometers. And you really shouldn’t drive any further. So realistically in everyday life it’s more like 429 kilometers instead of 506 kilometers – a difference of 77 kilometers.

And here is the complete table, with all the values ​​of the 22 tested electric cars in direct comparison, sorted according to the full range up to the drop in performance:

Place Model Range to standstill with 10% remaining battery with 20% remaining battery WLTP information WLTP deviation
1 BMW iX3 781km 665.6km 587.2km 770km +1.5%
2 Lucid Gravity 720km 598km 518km 748km −3.7%
3 Mercedes Benz CLA 675km 585km 514km 708km −4.7%
4 Mercedes Benz GLC 665km 578km 509km 643km +3.4%
5 Xpeng X9 646.3km 560km 494.6km 580km +11.4%
6 Polestar 3 601.1km 542.3km 479.3km 625km −3.8%
7 Mercedes Benz GLB 593km 520km 453km 563km +5.3%
8 Toyota C-HR+ 586.5km 507km 457km 607km −3.4%
9 Kia EV4 574.5km 505.3km 453.1km 594km −3.3%
10 Hyundai Ioniq 9 565.8km 504.4km 455.5km 600km −5.7%
11 Smart #5 556km 490.1 km 440km 540km +3.0%
12 Toyota bZ4X 505.9km 429km 400km 506km 0%
13 MG S6 501.6km 447.5km 401.4km 485km +3.4%
14 Citroën Ë-C5 Aircross 500km 430km 372km 513km −2.5%
15 Mazda 6e 484km 428km 387km 479km +1.2%
16 BYD Atto EVO 460km 407km 359km 470km −2.1%
17 MG IM6 446.1 km 404km 353.1km 505km −11.7%
18 Changan Deepal S05 431.6km 385km 350km 445km −3.1%
19 Hyundai Inster 372.5 km 342km 311.9km 360km +3.5%
20 KGM Musso 369km 339km 317km 379km −2.6%
21 Dongfeng Vigo 347.8km 321km 300km 340km +2.3%
22 Kia EV2 324.7km 280km 250km 308km +5.4%

A look at the models from Germany

In addition to the winner from BMW, three models from Mercedes-Benz and the Smart #5, which also belongs to Mercedes, were also at the start. The two electric SUVs GLB and GLC were each able to exceed their manufacturer specifications by 5.3 and 3.4 percent respectively. They come in seventh and fourth.

For the CLA, the range information had to be reduced by 4.7 percent. This is the third largest negative deviation in the entire test. Nevertheless, the sedan comes in third place in terms of overall range. For the relatively cheap Smart #5 it is at least enough for a place in the middle of the field (eleventh place).

Finally, a little note. The values ​​given above come from a summer test at mild temperatures. In winter, electric car drivers have to expect significantly higher range losses. In the El Prix winter test, all electric cars performed significantly worse.

Also interesting:

Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close

Adblock Detected

kindly turn off ad blocker to browse freely